Peer Review Banner

When Fish First Walked: The Transition from Fins to Limbs


Feature story Scientists have long sought the critical point at which fish evolved to the first land-walking creatures, when fins became limbs. Neil Shubin, PhD, associate dean for organismal and evolutionary biology, and provost for the Field Museum of Natural History, is one of these scientists. Recently his research has begun to provide the answers to one of evolutionary biology's most tantalizing questions: when did fins become limbs?

Features such as wrists, ankles and digits have long served as the line of demarcation between fish and tetrapods, with no direct evidence for how or when this transition took place. That has changed with the discovery of Tiktaalik roseae, a crocodile-like creature ranging from 4 to 9 feet in length. Shubin and his team, which included Ted Daeschler of the Academy of Natural Sciences and Farish Jenkins of Harvard University, discovered the Tiktaalik over four summers of exploration on Ellesmere Island in Artic Canada, a location chosen when Shubin and Daeschler found it listed in a textbook as being comprised of unexplored Devonian rock.

“It turned out that no one ever worked there before, except the geologists that mapped it,” says Shubin. “So after seeing that image in the textbook, we went out and tried to raise money, get the permits, and then ran a series of expeditions up there to find just the kind of creature we ended up discovering six years later.”

In the April 6, 2006 issue of Nature, Shubin and his colleagues detail how the pectoral fin of the Tiktaalik shows the beginnings of a tetrapod limb. The Tiktaalik looks like a fish, in that it has scales and fins, but the skeletal structure reveals those interesting tetrapod-like features, such as a wrist and finger-like appendages. The creature also has a back of the head, like a limbed-animal, an amphibian, and a neck, a first in the archaeological record.

Feature story

"It really is a mosaic of half limbed-animal and half fish, and that really tells us how fish evolved to walk on land, how they evolved to inhabit terrestrial ecosystems, and so forth. It is really remarkable, and has lots of surprises for us," explains Shubin. "It also has features we didn't fully expect before, such as ribs -big ribs- that attach to one another of a kind that we see only in animals that need to support itself in gravity. What's a fish doing with this kind of thing? Obviously, that tells us a lot about how fish developed to walk on land."

One of the most interesting aspects of this discovery is the fact that Tiktaalik leaves a clear record of a fish that had evolved to develop the very apparatuses necessary to venture through the shallows and even onto land, a discovery that provides insight into the transition of life on earth from aquatic to terrestrial.

“What we are dealing with are primitive pieces of our own bodies. This is not some dead end branch of evolution,” Shubin says. “This is our branch of evolution. This is our wrist. This is the evolution of our neck. This is the evolution of our ear. This is very much our distant past.”

 

Photo

Thumbnail of news story Valerie Jarrett to Lead Expanded Board of Medical Center
Valerie Jarrett has been appointed Chair of the University of Chicago Medical Center Board, Chair of a newly created Executive Committee of that board, and Vice-Chair of the University's Board of Trustees...

Thumbnail of news story
When Fish First Walked: The Transition from Fins to Limbs
Scientists have long sought the critical point at which fish evolved to the first land-walking creatures, when fins became limbs. Neil Shubin, PhD, associate dean for organismal and evolutionary biology...

Thumbnail of news story
Gordon Center for Integrative Science
On April 26, the University announced Ellen and Melvin Gordon's generous contribution of $25 million to name the Ellen and Melvin Gordon Center for Integrative Science. The Gordons' gift marks the University's third gift of $25 million or more in the past four months to support science and medicine...

Understanding the Golgi Apparatus
Cells are the basic units of life, and the characterization of cellular structure and function has been the challenge of cell biologists ever since these units were identified. Researchers have generally viewed cells as machines composed of stable, well-defined components...

Pritzker School of Medicine Rises in Rankings
The Pritzker School of Medicine was recognized by the latest U.S. News and World Report rankings as the 17th (tied with Vanderbilt University) highest ranked medical school in the country, up from 19th last year...

University of Chicago Practice Plan
The first lung transplant by the University of Chicago's Lung Transplant team was successfully performed on April 22. The 44 year old male diagnosed with scleroderma received a bilateral lung transplant...

Match Day 2006
On Thursday, March 16th, the 106 members of the 2006 graduating class of the Pritzker School of Medicine crowded into the P117 auditorium, along with many of their fellow students, friends and families to participate in the traditional match day rituals
...

Academic Affairs
New Hires, January 2006 - June 2006.

ACCOLADES
Recent Awards and Grants Information for Biological Sciences Division Faculty

BulletMore News & Events